Commons:News regarding the sexual content purge
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
On 7 May 2010, User:Jimbo Wales deleted 72 sex related images from Wikimedia Commons. Of these, only 38 remain deleted. He also encouraged other administrators to do the same, and rewrote the proposed Commons:Sexual content policy. A number of pressures may have encouraged this, including Larry Sanger reporting the project to the FBI for hosting child pornography, and FOX News contacting sponsors with warnings about sexual content on Wikipedia. In the wake of the resulting backlash, Jimbo surrendered his special technical privileges as a founder relating to editing privileges above those of a regular user, and much of the content was undeleted. Following is some of the resulting discussion and press surrounding this event.
External news stories[edit]
English[edit]
- 7 May 2010 - FOX News - "EXCLUSIVE: Wikipedia's Parent Company Starts Purging Porn From Its Websites"
- 7 May 2010 - Slashdot - "Wales Supports Purging Porn From Wikipedia"
- 7 May 2010 - XBIZ Newswire - "Wikipedia Porn Purge Includes Content of Adult Companies"
- 7 May 2010 - APEX News Network - "XXX – Porn to Be Removed from WikiPedia"
- 7 May 2010 - Pocket-lint - "Jimmy Wales plans Wikipedia porn purge"
- 8 May 2010 - Oneindia - "Wikimedia slammed for pornographic content on website"
- 9 May 2010 - The Register - "Jimbo Wales exiles 'porn' from Wikiland"
- 9 May 2010 - The Consumerist - "Wikipedia Begins Porn Purge-Fest"
- 10 May 2010 - FOX News - "Despite Content Purge, Pornographic Images Remain on Wikimedia"
- 10 May 2010 - BBC News - "Dispute brews over pornographic images on Wikimedia"
- 10 May 2010 - Digital Trends - "Wikipedia Purges Porn Following Reports of Child Porn"
- 10 May 2010 (?) - Helium - "Wikipedia porn scandal: How and why Wikipedia began removing pornography from their pages"
- 10 May 2010 - SiliconRepublic.com - "Wikimedia dumps porn following FoxNews probe"
- 10 May 2010 - ITWeb - "Porn exiled from Wikipedia"
- 10 May 2010 - Vanity Fair - "Child Pornography at the Center of Intra-Wikipedia Warfare"
- 10 May 2010 - The Huffington Post - "Wikipedia Porn Purge Sparks Dispute Over Adult Images On Wikimedia Sites"
- 10 May 2010 - CitizenLink - "Wikipedia Purges Site of Porn"
- 10 May 2010 - UPI.com - "Wikipedia in 'pornography' controversy"
- 10 May 2010 - TechCentral.ie - "Jimmy Wales wades into Wikipedia porn debate"
- 10 May 2010 - The Punch (Nigeria) - "Dispute brews over pornographic images on Wikimedia"
- 10 May 2010 - Dailytech.com - "Fox News Claims Responsibility for Wikipedia Porn Purge"
- 11 May 2010 - newser - "Porn Battle Rocks Wiki"
- 11 May 2010 - TechEye - "Internal battle at Wikimedia over 'pornographic images'"
- 11 May 2010 - Daily News & Analysis - "Wikimedia still hosting some pornographic images of children"
- 11 May 2010 - Daily Telegraph - "Wikipedia porn row sees founder give up his editing privileges"
- 11 May 2010 - The Inquirer - "Wikipedia roiled by porn row - Wales gives up censorship privileges", Nick Farrell
- 11 May 2010 - The Week - "Wikipedia's war on porn"
- 11 May 2010 - Boise Weekly - "FOX News Officially Steps into Activism"
- 11 May 2010 - NetworkWorld - "Wikimedia child porn row escalates"
- 11 May 2010 - [H]ard|OCP - "Wikimedia Starts Purging Porn From Its Websites"
- 11 May 2010 - Caledonian Mercury - "War of words over ‘wicked’ Wikipedia", Allan Laing
- 11 May 2010 - The Gaea Times - "Wikimedia still hosting some pornographic images of children"
- 11 May 2010 - Robot 6 @ Comic Book Resources - "Comics A.M. | The comics Internet in two minutes"
- 11 May 2010 - DaniWeb - "Wikimedia Scrambles to Fight Child Pornography Claims"
- 11 May 2010 - TECH.BLORGE.com - "Wikipedia porn row leads to Jimmy Wales giving up editing privileges"
- 12 May 2010 - ITProPortal - "Wikimedia Looking To Purge Adult Content From Wikipedia"
- 12 May 2010 - The Guardian - "Wikipedia's porn purge, and cleaning up for the iPad"
- 12 May 2010 - ZDNet - "Long past time for Wikimedia to grow up"
- 14 May 2010 - FOX News - "EXCLUSIVE: Shakeup at Wikipedia in Wake of Porn Purge"
- 17 May 2010 – Computerworld – FOX News' cunning Wikipedia child porn agenda
- 17 May 2010 – Catholic Online – Obscene images shake up Internet encyclopedia
- 17 May 2010 – The Guardian – Wikimedia: "Fox News's campaign against us is nonsense"
- 18 May 2010 – New Statesman – Wikimedia counsel dismisses Fox allegations of pornography as "nonsense"
- 21 May 2010 - FOX News - Wikipedia Reports Porn (video)
Dutch[edit]
- 10 May 2010 - ZDNet België - "Wikipedia verwijdert porno. Bij artikel over pedofilie" (Wikipedia remove porno. for article on pedophilia)
- 10 May 2010 - De Telegraaf - "Grote schoonmaak op Wikipedia" (Big cleanup on Wikipedia)
- 10 May 2010 - NOS - Porno op Wikipedia? (Porn on wikipedia?)
- 11 May 2010 - De Morgen - "Pornografisch Wikimedia ligt onder vuur" (Pornographic Wikimedia under fire)
- 12 May 2010 - metro - "Wikipedia-oprichter onder vuur" (Wikipedia founder under fire)
French[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - Infos-du-net.com - "Wikipedia et la pornographie : le FBI s’en mêle" (Wikipedia and pornography: the FBI gets involved)
- 11 May 2010 - Canoë - "Purge de matériel porno sur Wikipedia" (Purge of pornographic material on Wikipedia)
- 11 May 2010 - Slate - "Wikipedia critiqué pour sa purge pornographique" (Wikipedia criticized for its pornographic purge)
- 11 May 2010 - Fluctuat.net - "Wikipedia sans images porno" (Wikipedia without porno images)
- 12 May 2010 - ActuaLitté - "Wikimedia entame une purge anti-pornographie sur Wikipedia" (Wikimedia starts an anti-pornography purge on Wikipedia)
- 12 May 2010 - Clubic - "Wikipedia critiqué pour le filtrage de ses contenus" (Wikipedia critized for its content filtering)
- 14 May 2010 - PCWorld.fr - "Wikipedia, pornographie et filtrage des contenus"
- 15 May 2010 - Clubic - "La semaine de Flock : le Seigneur des réseaux, ou le précieux ridicule", including caricature "FoxNews tacle Wikipédia"
- 17 May 2010 - Silicon.fr - "Aucune démission en vue, Jimmy Wales reste chez Wikimedia"
- 17 May 2010 - Gizmodo.fr - "Wikimédia plonge dans le chaos à la suite de la démission de Jimmy Wales"
- 18 May 2010 - 20 minutes - "Wikipédia, Fox News et les images pornographiques"
- 18 May 2010 - Mind Overflow - "Quand la Fox a cherché à imposer sa morale à la Wikimedia Foundation"
- 19 may 2010 - Le Monde.fr - "Fox News déclenche des remous à la fondation Wikimedia"
German[edit]
- 9 May 2010 - Heise.de - "Porno-Streit in Wikipedia eskaliert"
- 9 May 2010 - Bild.de - "Porno-Streit bei Wikipedia entbrannt"
- 9 May 2010 - contator - "Pornopedia-Streit"
- 10 May 2010 - chip.de - "Wikipedia: Zensurvorwurf und Porno-Streit"
- 10 May 2010 - focus.de - "Porno-Diskussion in der Online-Enzyklopädie"
- 10 May 2010 - derStandard.at - "Porno-Streit spaltet Wikipedia-Community" (based on Heise.de article)
- 10 May 2010 - DiePresse.com - "Wikipedia: Streit um pornografische Bilder eskaliert"
- 10 May 2010 - Winload.de - "Wikipedia: Gründer löscht Porno-Bilder, Community tobt"
- 10 May 2010 - krone.at - "Sex-Bilder entfernt - Wikipedia versinkt im Streit"
- 10 May 2010 - DigiWeb - "Streit um Porno-Fotos in der Wikipedia-Community" (based on Bild.de article)
- 10 May 2010 - Augsburger Allgemeine - "Porno-Streit bei Wikipedia"
- 11 May 2010 - oe24.at - "Porno-Streit bei Wikipedia eskaliert"
- 11 May 2010 - computer.t-online.de - "Wikipedia-Nutzer wehren sich gegen Porno-Löschungen"
- 11 May 2010 - sueddeutsche.de - "Sex, Intrigen und Wikipedia"
- 17 May 2010 - Spiegel Online - Jimmy Wales ist nicht mehr gleicher als die anderen
- 17 May 2010 – Meedia – http://meedia.de/nc/details-topstory/article/wikipedia--fhrungskrise-nach-porno-lschaktion_100028012.html?tx_ttnews[backPid]=23&cHash=8fe81c65fd Gründer Jimmy Wales gab Admin-Rechte ab. Wikipedia: Krise nach Porno-Löschaktion
Hungarian[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - index.hu - Kiirtják a pornót a Wikipediáról
- 11 May 2010 - origo.hu - Pornó miatt veszekednek a wikipédisták
Indonesian[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - Kompas - "Wikipedia Kesandung Gambar Porno"
Italian[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - ITespresso.it - "Wikipedia si unisce alla crociata contro il porno"
- 11 May 2010 - punto-informatico.it - "Wikipedia, pornografia al bando"
- 11 May 2010 - Corriere della Sera - "I wikipediani e la polemica sul porno"
- 11 May 2010 - blitz quotidiano - "Wikipedia e le foto porno: la denuncia, la purga, la protesta degli utenti"
- 12 May 2010 - wired.it Wikipedia e porno: viaggio ai limiti della conoscenza
- 17 May 2010 - Sky - Niente porno, siamo su Wikipedia
- 17 May 2010 - punto-informatico.it - A Wikipedia tutto ok, parola di Jimbo
Norwegian[edit]
- 10 May 2010 - ITavisen -Vil ha Wales ut av Wikipedia
Polish[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - Komputer Świat - "Wikipedia pod porno-cenzurą"
Russian[edit]
- 11 May 2010 - webplanet.ru - Wikipedia очищается от порнографии
- 11 May 2010 - encyclopedia.ru - Википедия избавляется от «откровенных» изображений
- 17 May 2010 - Infox.ru - Основатель Wikipedia перестарался в борьбе с порнографией
- 18 May 2010 - newsru.com - Основателю Википедии урезали полномочия за перегибы в борьбе с порнографией
- 19 May 2010 - ruformator.ru - Основатель Wikipedia лишился прав администратора из-за порнографии
- 19 May 2010 - Деловой Петербург - Из-за взглядов на порнографический контент основатель "Википедии" лишился администраторских прав
- 19 May 2010 - Компьютерра-Онлайн - "Википедию" уличили в хранении недозволенного
Other external discussion[edit]
- 7 May 2010 - Weblog Archivalia - Jimbeau zensiert ... äh ... reinigt Wikimedia Commons von Porno-Fotos und historischen Kunstwerken
- 10 May 2010 - CrunchGear - "Wikipedia finds out first-hand that, in America, the naked human body is a terribly sinful thing", Nicholas Deleon
- 10 May 2010 - ResourceShelf - "Jimmy Wales Exiles ‘Porn’ from Wikiland But Gives Up His Founder Privileges" (excerpt of The Register article)
- 10 May 2010 - World's Breaking News - "Wikipedia’s Parent Company: We’re No Porn !" (copy of first FOX article)
- Pluspedia entry
- Reddit discussion of the 10 May BBC article
- Discussion at Wikipedia Review :- *The board speaks on porn, Ten most underreported facts about Wikiporngate, Sanger comments on his block
Internal discussion[edit]
- en:Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2010-05-10/Commons_deletions, en:Wikipedia:Wikipedia_Signpost/2010-05-10/In_the_news
- The Foundation's FAQ
- User talk:Jimbo Wales, User talk:Jimbo Wales/Archive
- Commons:Sexual content, Commons talk:Sexual content
- Commons:Village Pump, Commons_talk:Sexual_content/Village_pump/2010-5-7
- Commons:Undeletion_requests/Current_requests
- Discussion at En and other projects (from Commons:Village_pump#Discussions_on_customer_projects):
- de:Wikipedia:Kurier's 10 Mai 2010 story "Vulva Reloaded + Jimbo"
Notable internal statements[edit]
- Official statement by the WMF Board of Trustees
- Personally authored statements by individual WMF board members: Kat Walsh, Ting Chen (partially retracted), Stuart West, Samuel Klein sent many messages on the subject to foundation-l, Jimmy Wales participated in many discussions (see above)
- Statement on the role of the board by former member Florence Devouard.