Commons talk:Wiki Loves Monuments 2012 in Switzerland/Results
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Euch ist aber schon klar, dass das Zentrum Paul Klee kein Kulturdenkmal ist, oder? Nur die Sammlung ist ein A-Objekt, das Haus ist ja gerade mal 7 Jahre alt. --FA2010 (talk) 09:16, 31 October 2012 (UTC)
Pre-selection
[edit]I challenge these criteria.
- monuments not listed in the official list
- You need to do that more thoroughly. See above.
- participants without contacts (email not present)
- What? Any wiki talk page is enough possibility of contact.
- low resolution and low quality (i.e. out of focus or bad exposure)
- Well, o.k., but why have overexposed images shown up even in the top 10?
- problems of privacy (clear identification of people taken in the photos)
- If de minimis: not a problem.
- presence of unrelated objects in connection with the monuments (i.e. scaffolds or cranes)
- If there's scaffolding in an image, the connection with the monument is pretty clear: it's being renovated. Documenting things like that that may be encyclopedically very worthwhile (while the thousandst boring picture of Kapellenbrücke is, well, _not_).
Just my 2 cents worth. What I want to say: You'd have to tell participants things like this before sending them out to photographe if you don't want to upset people next time. --FA2010 (talk) 16:37, 25 November 2012 (UTC)