Commons:Wiki Loves Monuments 2015/Jury Tool

See the description of a jury tool at Commons:WLX Jury Tool.

Started 1st Round

Algeria

Contact: Vikoula5 (Reda-kwikimedia-dz.org)

Latvia

Contact: Voll (vollyahoo.com)

Sweden

Contact: abbedabb (albinwikimedia.se)

Thailand

Contact: taweethaも

Tunisia

Contact: touzrimounirgmail.com

Started 2nd Round

Brazil

Contact: Rodrigo Padula (rodrigopadulawikimedia.org.br)

Estonia

• 4 jury members, 2 rounds (yes/no at first round and then rating in second

France

• 3 jurors, first round yes/no

Italy

Contact: Federico Leva (WMIT)

• in selection rounds, when an image was approved (or rejected) by at least 2 jurors, don't show it to further jurors;
• images in Category:Images from Wiki Loves Busto Arsizio 2015 should have their own selection round (where 1 vote suffices to approve or reject); we may need to split the other 11k images into 2-3 parallel rounds;
• don't show an image again to a juror if they decided to skip it; let jurors see a list of images they skipped voting (ideally also those they approved/discarded), to revisit their vote;
• in star voting, have a double set of stars (for two criteria which may be both voted or not, with same weight).

@Federico Leva (WMIT): , how many jurors do you have?

I can give split images in portion(1), portion(2) .. portion(n)

and give them to jurors so each portion will be rated by separate j jurors

If j is 2 then "in selection rounds, when an image was approved (or rejected) by at least 2 jurors, don't show it to further jurors;" will become unneeded (only 2 jurors per portion anyway) --Ilya (talk) 07:03, 8 October 2015 (UTC)

distributed among 15 pre-jurors, each image to 3 people --Ilya (talk) 12:57, 8 October 2015 (UTC)

Thanks, works great! I'll let you know what subcategories we need to have their own round/portion. --Federico Leva (WMIT) (talk) 13:07, 8 October 2015 (UTC)

• Additional parallel and separate rounds needed for sub-contests (star voting), independently from the round 1, one for each category or list of files below.
  • Terremoto: specific monuments (5 accounts needed) Ministry people changed their mind
  • Emilia: recursive category (5 accounts needed) Ministry people changed their mind
  • Piemonte: Category:Images from Wiki Loves Piemonte 2015‎ (3? accounts needed) (they made their own)
  • Genova: Category:Images from Wiki Loves Monuments Genova 2015‎ (they set up their own)
  • Busto: Category:Images from Wiki Loves Busto Arsizio 2015‎ (3 accounts needed)
• We also have two sub-contests out of images selected in round 1.
  • FIAF: all images which got score 3 or more in round 1 (9 accounts needed)
  • ICOM: images in Commons:Wiki Loves Monuments 2015 in Italy/ICOM (5 accounts needed)

Round 1 is over. For the main jury which is judging the images selected out of round 1, we need a star voting with two 5-star ratings per photo (same weight), 8 new accounts. All the photos with score 3 in round 1 will participate.

OK, giving 294 photos selected by 3 prejurors to the round 2--Ilya (talk) 12:44, 22 October 2015 (UTC)

How would you name the criteria 1 and 2? I'll show how it works, maybe it's not what you might expect --Ilya (talk) 12:46, 22 October 2015 (UTC)

created FIAF and Busto Arsizio rounds --Ilya (talk) 12:28, 28 October 2015 (UTC)

Netherlands

Contact: (meijerwikimedia.nl)

• 6 jury members, 2 rounds (yes/no at first round, image will be seen only by 3 jurors from the start and then rating in second)

Russia

Contact: putnik, Alexander

Initial cutoff: size > 1 Mb

Pre-selection (yes/no): 6 jurors, 1 juror/photo

First round (grades): same 6 jurors, each juror grades each photo

Second round (grades): + 2 external jurors

Started 3rd Round

Iran

Contact: LilyOfTheWest (lilyofthewest.wikimediagmail.com)

Slovakia

• 2 prejurors, 4 jurors, 2 rounds (yes/no at first round and then rating in second)

Spain

• 6 jurors, 3 per image, first round yes/no

Started 4th Round

Ukraine

Ukraine

• preselecting:

  7 logins for the organizing committee + 7 logins for volunteers (pictures less than 2Mp and/or with bad ids are to be in a separate portion)

• local jury: