File:Brief Jan Stalmans - Paul Van Hoeydonck 11-09-2007.jpg

From Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Original file(1,700 × 2,338 pixels, file size: 561 KB, MIME type: image/jpeg)

Captions

Captions

Add a one-line explanation of what this file represents
Public domain This work has been released into the public domain by its author, Jan Stalmans. This applies worldwide.
In some countries this may not be legally possible; if so:
Jan Stalmans grants anyone the right to use this work for any purpose, without any conditions, unless such conditions are required by law.

Description This is a letter written by Jan Stalmans sent to Paul Van Hoeydonck who returned it to Jan Stalmans with a handwritten answer on it
Date Letter written on 11 September 2007
Source Jan Stalmans
Author Jan Stalmans and Paul Van Hoeydonck
Permission
(Reusing this file)
public domain
  • Permission from Jan Stalmans to release it in the public domain in OTRS Ticket#: 2007111010011079
    • 11-11-2007 Ondergetekende, Jan Stalmans, bevestig hiermede eigenaar te zijn van de brief van 11 september 2007 waarop de kunstenaar PAUL VAN HOEYDONCK eigenhandig een verklaring geschreven heeft i.v.m."Fallen Astronaut". IK GEEF HIERBIJ DE TOELATING OM DEZE BRIEF VRIJ TE GEVEN IN HET PUBLIEKE DOMEIN EN DAT DEZE BIJGEVOLG PUBLIEK MAG GEMAAKT WORDEN ZONDER ENIGE BEPERKINGEN. Jan Stalmans

Who is who[edit]

Jan Stalmans - Belgian, Master Sociale Wetenschappen, Paul Harris Fellow Rotary International, autor of publications about many artists including Paul Van Hoeydonck, Paul Delvaux, Octave Landuyt and Pol Mara. Friends with Paul Van Hoeydonck for more then 40 years.
w:en:Paul Van Hoeydonck the Belgian artist who has made the sculpture w:en:Fallen Astronaut that was the first and at present only piece or art on the moon.

Why[edit]

The article w:en:Fallen Astronaut on the English language Wikipedia, and other articles related to it and also the articles about it on other Wikipedia language editions have contained incorrect information for years.

The information on Wikipedia stated that Paul Van Hoeydonck had sold 950 signed copies of the Fallen Astronaut for $750 a piece.

Jan Stalmans has sent a letter (this letter) to inform him that he had read this on Wikipedia and to ask him of that was correct. Paul Van Hoeydonck responded by writing a note on the letter and sending it back to clarify this.

The text of this letter[edit]

the part written by Jan Stalmans (printed)[edit]

Nederlands:

Beste Paul,

Op de site Wikipedia lees ik over het beeldje Fallen Astronaut. (fotokopij in bijlage) Is deze info juist?

Hoeveel zijn er nu werkelijk onder uw handtekening en toelating gemaakt? Ik weet:

  • 1 ex op de maan
  • 1 ex in Smithsonian Institute
  • 1 ex Koning Boudewijn
  • 1 ex Oostende Museum W.Van den Bussche
  • 1 ex Restany in Vesuvius
  • 1 ex bij ons

Hartelijke groeten en graag je te lezen.

Jan

English:

Dear Paul, I read about the Fallen Astronaut statue on Wikipedia. (photocopy in attachment) Is this information correct?

How many of them have currently been made with your signature and permission?

I know:

  • 1 x on the Moon
  • 1 x at the Smithsonian Institute
  • 1 x King Boudewijn
  • 1 x Oostende Museum W.Van den Bussche
  • 1 x Restany in Vesuvius
  • 1 x with us

Best greetings and hope to read you soon. Jan

the part written by Paul Van Hoeydonck (handwritten)[edit]

Nederlands:

Ik heb in Antwerpen in die periode 50 exemplaren laten maken. De meeste hiervan zijn ongetekend in mijn bezit, buiten deze welke in bruikleen gegeven zijn in Redou in het Museum voor Ruimtevaart en in het Vlaamse Parlement.

Buiten 1 exemplaar, verkocht in die periode door Foncke heb ik nooit 1 cent gekregen voor een beeldje dat ik trouwens weiger te verkopen ondanks de voorstellen die men mij maakt. Handtekening Beste groeten, Paul

English:

I have ordered in that time the production in Antwerp of 50 specimens. The majority remained in my possession unsigned, except one I gave on loan to the Redou Museum for Aerospace and the Flemish Parliament.

Except for one specimen sold at that time by Foncke I have never received a penny for any statue which I refuse to sell despite the offers I receive.

Signature Best greetings, Paul

Other relevant source[edit]

  • Book
    • Title: Kunstmonografie: Paul Van Hoeydonck
    • Written by: Willy Van den Bussche
    • Language: dutch
    • Publication year: 1980
    • Printed by: Lannoo, from Tielt, Belgium
    • ISBN 90-209-0885-5
    • page 16 and 17
Nederlands:

Pagina 16

De tentoonstelling bij Waddell in 1972 waarbij het multipliceren van het beeldje werd aangekondigd zou de start betekenen van een polemiek die de kunstenaar, onschuldig, tot op heden nog steeds een negatief imago blijft geven. De voorziene reeks multiples werd evenwel nooit gemaakt.


Pagina 17

Na de polemiek met de NASA trok Van Hoeydonck echter definitief zijn toelating tot het multipliceren in.

English:

Page 16

The exhibition by Waddell in 1972 by which the replication of the statue was announced was the start of a polemic that the artist, innocently, until at present still gives a negative image. The planed series of replicas was never made however.

Page 17

After the polemic with the NASA, Van Hoeydonck withdrew definitively its permission for replication.

OTRS emails[edit]

All emails about this are under Ticket#: 2007111010011079 in dutch.

File history

Click on a date/time to view the file as it appeared at that time.

Date/TimeThumbnailDimensionsUserComment
current19:35, 11 November 2007Thumbnail for version as of 19:35, 11 November 20071,700 × 2,338 (561 KB)Walter (talk | contribs){{PD-author|[https://secure.wikimedia.org/otrs/index.pl?Action=AgentTicketZoom&TicketID=1187633&ArticleID=1453950#1453950 Jan Stalmans]}} {{Information |Description= |Source= |Date= |Author= |Permission= |other_versions= }}

There are no pages that use this file.

File usage on other wikis

The following other wikis use this file:

Metadata